The CSR Newsletters are a freely-available resource generated as a dynamic complement to the textbook, Strategic Corporate Social Responsibility: Sustainable Value Creation.

To sign-up to receive the CSR Newsletters regularly during the fall and spring academic semesters, e-mail author David Chandler at david.chandler@ucdenver.edu.

Showing posts with label social entrepreneurship. Show all posts
Showing posts with label social entrepreneurship. Show all posts

Thursday, November 18, 2021

Strategic CSR - BRCC

Following on from Tuesday's newsletter, the article in the url below announces the public listing of Black Rifle Coffee Company (BRCC). If you are unfamiliar with BRCC, I wrote about it earlier this year (see Strategic CSR – Black Rifle Coffee):

"The article in the url below profiles Black Rifle Coffee – a roasting company in Salt Lake City that, I would argue, is just as good an example of strategic CSR in action as Patagonia. … While enacting a very different set of values to Patagonia and, as a result, appealing to a completely different part of the population, the point is that Black Rifle stands for something and that thing is highly valued by a specific market segment."

In the article featured in today's newsletter, the company is announcing its listing via a merger with a special-purpose acquisition company (SPAC):

"Black Rifle Coffee Co. is going public by combining with a special-purpose acquisition company in a merger that values the coffee seller focused on military veterans at about $1.7 billion, the companies said. Known for its pricier coffee and firearms-themed products such as its AK-47 Espresso Blend, Black Rifle is combining with the SPAC SilverBox Engaged Merger Corp. I. Black Rifle also sells branded apparel and produces digital content to promote its products to veterans and first responders."

While SPACs have a spotty track record and are often associated with dubious business propositions, what is interesting about this announcement is that the merger is positioning BRCC as a social enterprise:

"Founded by former Green Beret Evan Hafer in 2014, Black Rifle has capitalized on consumers' desire to shop at brands that support social causes. Mr. Hafer vowed in 2017 to hire 10,000 veterans after Starbucks Corp. promised to hire 10,000 refugees following then President Donald Trump's executive order barring more refugees from entering the country."

More specifically, the merger is enabling the company to validate this claim by altering its legal status:

"As part of the deal, Black Rifle plans to reorganize as a public-benefit corporation, meaning it will have fiduciary duties both to shareholders and social good. Many startups have become PBCs, with investors increasingly giving priority to companies' missions. 'We want to do well for ourselves and do good for our community,' Joe Reece, the SPAC's executive chairman, said."

Relating back to the comparison I made back in March with Patagonia, and given that Patagonia is also a public benefit corporation (since 2012), I am struck by how different the values and guiding missions of these two companies are, but how they are equally appealing to their specific set of key stakeholders:

"Today, about half of Black Rifle's roughly 600 employees are military veterans, a total that Mr. Hafer said in an interview he expects to grow after the SPAC deal."

Take care
David

David Chandler
© Sage Publications, 2020

Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: https://study.sagepub.com/chandler5e 
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Black Rifle Coffee, SPAC to Merge
By Amrith Ramkumar
November 3, 2021
The Wall Street Journal
Late Edition – Final
B3

Monday, November 23, 2020

Strategic CSR - Free speech (II)

One of last week's newsletters focused on the issue of free speech (Strategic CSR – Free speech). The article in the url below expands on this argument, demonstrating some of the challenges (and collateral damage) of entrusting for-profit firms with the task of defining the parameters of acceptable content that is allowed to be disseminated via their platforms:

"What do a small business that sell socks packaged by homeless youth and a start-up that makes bracelets from life vests once worn by refugees have to do with the spread of misinformation during the presidential election season? Nothing, thought the entrepreneurs who started them, until Facebook notified them that their ads had been pulled because they fell into a category of 'social issues, elections or politics' that were being blocked by the site."

The challenges of separating right from wrong are particularly stark when the effort to define them is systematic – in other words when it is algorithmic, which necessarily generalizes about topics that, in reality, are extremely nuanced:

"The social media giant announced last week that it was extending a ban imposed on certain ads during the election to prevent the dissemination of false information. The prohibition has ensnared a number of socially driven businesses with no direct connection to partisan politics. Companies connected to issues like hunger, the environment and immigration, many of which rely heavily on social media to draw customers to their websites, have seen their access abruptly cut off."

The trouble is that, in writing algorithms (as in using data to predict any outcome), the prediction is only as good as the data available. In other words, the resulting algorithm can only account for what has happened before when predicting what might happen in the future. This conservative approach necessarily entails generalizations that lead to unintended consequences:

"In the run-up to the 2016 election, deceptive and distorted information spread by Russian automated accounts and others on social media platforms like Facebook, Instagram and YouTube was designed to influence voters. Some of the accounts generated posts about social issues, such as civil and women's rights, that proved divisive."

While the lost ad revenues are merely a drop in the ocean for Facebook, the ability to advertise in the run-up to the holiday season is life and death for many small businesses:

"Advertising on Facebook is a lifeline for Epimonia, a Minneapolis-based company that makes and sells bracelets and other items made from the discarded life jackets worn by refugees fleeing on flimsy boats to Europe. The company spends several thousand dollars a year to advertise on Facebook, which targets users who have a favorable view of refugees based on the interests listed on their profiles. … 'Not being able to run ads before the holidays could put us out of business,' said [founder and CEO, Mohamed] Malim, who employs a handful of refugees to make bracelets, beanies and T-shirts."

The lasting impression is that this is a fascinating topic that is incredibly difficult to navigate – whether for CEOs trying to run a company or social media platforms trying to determine what content should be allowed on their platforms. This difficulty is magnified when the affected stakeholders really care about a particular issue and are willing to pushback if their concerns are not acknowledged or accommodated. But, I think these cases (where stakeholders care deeply) also fall into the 'exception' category I tried to demarcate in my post last week. The trouble is that everything cannot be an exception or else no work ever gets done. But, whenever a bright line is drawn, unintended consequences mean there are inevitably innocent victims caught up in the blunt solution that has been imposed on such a complicated issue. In short, the key questions are 'Where should we draw the line?' and 'Who gets to draw it?' So far, it is not at all clear that, when considering society as a whole, the best answer to either question is for-profit firms.

Take care
David

David Chandler
© Sage Publications, 2020

Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: https://study.sagepub.com/chandler5e 
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Why Did Facebook Mute Philanthropic Businesses?
By Miriam Jordan
November 18, 2020
The New York Times
Late Edition – Final
A14

Monday, March 26, 2018

Strategic CSR - Unilever

I don't understand the difference between a social enterprise and a for-profit firm. Take this example from the article in the url below about the founding of Unilever:
 
"To most of Unilever's customers, the state of the world is probably the last thing on their minds as they push their shopping carts through the supermarket, tossing in Ben & Jerry's ice cream, Dove soap, Lipton tea, Hellmann's mayonnaise, and other Unilever products. It's hard to imagine that eco-disasters might someday lead to those items disappearing from shelves. But to Unilever, which was born as a solution to a crisis, the potential for calamity seems real enough. The company got its start in the 1880s, right here in this picture-perfect redbrick village near Liverpool called Port ­Sunlight—named after the world's first packaged, branded bar of soap and the company's founding product. It was created in an effort to stop rampant epidemics and child deaths amid the grinding poverty and squalor of Victorian England. Nearly 130 years later, there is still an acute sense at Unilever that the world needs fixing."
 
How is Unilever not a social enterprise? The firm uses market forces to solve societal problems, just like all for-profit firms. In contrast, take this example of TOMS Shoes (see Strategic CSR – TOMS Shoes), which is usually described as a social enterprise. It is essentially the same thing (an organization using market forces to solve a societal problem), but just not as effective as Unilever. At best, the value TOMS is adding seems dubious; in fact, it might be doing more harm than good:
 
"Did you buy TOMS shoes because you want to make the world a better place? If so, you should be a little mad. TOMS, of course, is an accessory company that markets itself like a charity … When someone buys a pair of TOMS shoes in the US, for instance, the company donates a pair of shoes to a child in a poor country like Haiti. … But TOMS and the many other companies like it are the charitable equivalents of yes men. They're telling you what they think you want to hear in order to get what they want (for you to purchase trendy, pricey accessories), not what you need to hear in order to do what you want (to have your purchase to do as much good in the world as it can)."
 
CSR advocates talk about the need for companies to "do good" instead of focusing on profit as if economic problems and social problems are independent of each other. However, a simple thought experiment highlights the overly-simplistic nature of this forced dichotomy. Is feeding people a social problem or an economic problem? Of course, there are hundreds of for-profit food manufacturers (not to mention the hundreds of thousands of restaurants) that produce food and distribute it widely (and efficiently) to whole populations of people. What about clothing people—a social problem or an economic problem? A visit to the shopping mall will quickly reveal how efficiently for-profit firms have essentially eradicated the supply of clothes as a challenge for all but the most deprived societies. Or, what about providing internet access to every household in the country—economic or social? Certainly, you could make an argument that, today, a family is essentially excluded from many aspects of society if it cannot get online; yet, internet provision in most developed economies is the sole responsibility of the private sector (as it is for the food and apparel industries).
 
Strategic CSR argues that for-profit firms are the best hope we have to institute change on the scale and speed necessary to make a difference. I tell my students, if you want to "do good" in the world, join a corporation. So-called social enterprises make us feel good, but are more akin to rearranging the deckchairs on the Titanic.
 
Take care
David
 
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: https://study.sagepub.com/chandler4e
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/
 
 
Unilever CEO Paul Polman's Plan to Save the World
By Vivienne Walt
February 16, 2017
Fortune
 

Tuesday, October 20, 2015

Strategic CSR - TOMS Shoes

The article in the url below deconstructs TOMS Shoes' business model, suggesting it is a means for consumers to feel good, rather than to do good:
 
"Did you buy TOMS shoes because you want to make the world a better place? If so, you should be a little mad. TOMS, of course, is an accessory company that markets itself like a charity … When someone buys a pair of TOMS shoes in the US, for instance, the company donates a pair of shoes to a child in a poor country like Haiti. … But TOMS and the many other companies like it are the charitable equivalents of yes men. They're telling you what they think you want to hear in order to get what they want (for you to purchase trendy, pricey accessories), not what you need to hear in order to do what you want (to have your purchase to do as much good in the world as it can)."
 
The point of the article is that, while TOMS may well be well-intentioned, it is not an efficient way to help those most in need:
 
"TOMS tells you that you that making the world a better place is all about you: that you know best how to help poor people, and that you are so powerful that it will take barely any effort on your part to make a huge difference in the world. … But the truth is that while that kind of messaging is evidently a great way to sell trendy shoes, or to otherwise raise money, it's not a very good way to do charity. At best, it's inefficient: It focuses on programs that waste your hard-earned cash by failing to do the most good per dollar. At worst, it promotes a view of the world's poor as helpless, ineffective people passively waiting for trinkets from shoe-buying Americans. While the shoes themselves probably won't lead to any kind of disaster, that worldview can lead to bad policies and real, serious harm."
 
The author argues that there is a series of assumptions that underpin the business models of firms like TOMS that do not necessarily make sense. For example, TOMS founder, Blake Mycoskie (see Strategic CSR – Toms Shoes) goes to a poor country and sees that the children there do not have shoes. As such, he decides to set-up a company that will provide them with shoes. The assumption is that they need shoes and that, if they have them, their lives will be better than they were without shoes. The author of the article says this is not necessarily so. Instead, she suggests that giving money is a lot more effective way to help those in need. Why should Mycoskie know what is best for these people when, if you give them money, they can decide for themselves? The author notes that there are even examples of TOMS shoes finding their way onto the black market in areas where they are distributed. In other words, rather than wear the shoes, people sell them to get money to help them buy what they really need to improve their lives:
 
"There's a different approach. Instead of giving shoes, why not give poor people cash? If shoes are really what the recipients need, then they can go ahead and buy them. But if not, their options are wide open: They can put the money toward medicine or a crop loan or school fees. Or they can use it to invest in some kind of income-generating venture, such as livestock or a small business."
 
For me, the article is valuable because it demonstrates the limits of what has come to be called 'social entrepreneurism.' There are two points that I want to make about social entrepreneurs:
 
1. I do not understand the difference between what people call a "social entrepreneur" and a regular entrepreneur. Usually, definitions of social entrepreneurs revolve around some desire to solve social problems using business solutions. Isn't that what all entrepreneurs do? If I set up a clothing business or a food store, I am trying to clothe people and feed people, respectively. Are those not social goals?
 
2. In fact, what people call social entrepreneurs today (e.g., TOMS Shoes) are really unsustainable business models that are propelled by consumers' philanthropy. In other words, TOMS Shoes survives because consumers are willing to pay a ridiculous amount of money for very cheap shoes and trust that TOMS Shoes will ensure someone who cannot afford a pair of shoes will receive one. Now, if purchasing shoes for the poor is the goal, I agree with the article's author that it would be more effective to donate the amount of money that TOMS is charging consumers to do this to a charity. TOMS Shoes may have become adept at establishing the supply chain necessary to donate shoes worldwide, but I am guessing there was a huge amount of inefficiency involved in setting it up and that TOMS was probably reinventing the wheel (i.e., that supply chain already existed through other means).
 
The combination of these two points brings me to the main point of today's newsletter – if any of my students approach me and ask how they can make a difference in the world, I tell them they should join a for-profit firm, rather than join a nonprofit or become a social entrepreneur. And I emphasize that the larger the firm they join, the more good they will likely be doing. For-profit firms exist to create value and are usually many times more efficient at doing so than "social entrepreneurs." As I have said a number of times in this newsletter, businesses are not perfect (which is why Strategic CSR exists), but it is these for-profit organizations, embedded within the structure of a market forces, that represent the future. If we want to build a sustainable economic model that does not transport us back to the nineteenth century (or before!), we need to work with what centuries of economic exchange and knowledge of human psychology have taught us about efficiency and progress.
 
For a similar analysis and more insight into the counter-productive effects of TOMS Shoes, see this short video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hX0g66MWbrk
 
Take care
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/
 
 
Buying TOMS shoes is a terrible way to help poor people
By Amanda Taub
July 23, 2015
Vox Topics
 

Friday, November 2, 2012

Strategic CSR - Toilets

The article in the url below is amazing for two reasons. It reports recent attempts by The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation to reinvent the toilet. Apparently, there has not been much innovation in this vital tool since the 16th century:

“In fact, with the exception of S-traps to contain odours, flush toilets have changed little since Sir John Harington installed one in Richmond Palace for Queen Elizabeth I in the late 1590s.”

The first reason this article is amazing is because of the winning designs submitted by scientists and social entrepreneurs from around the world. This is not a sexy area, but the innovation the contest generated is outstanding. Here is the description of the winning design:

“The winning toilet is smarter still. It has been developed by Michael Hoffman of the California Institute of Technology, and has earned him the $100,000 first prize. His toilet uses solar panels to power an electrochemical system that turns waste into useful things. One is a compound which oxidises the salts in urine to generate chlorine. This creates a mildly disinfecting solution that can be used to flush the toilet. The second is hydrogen, which is suitable for cooking or for powering a fuel cell to produce electricity. The residue from the process can be used as fertiliser.”

The second reason this article is amazing is because it demonstrates, yet again, the ability of Bill and Melinda Gates to influence greatly the field of health, education, and overseas aid. When Gates brings his attention and intelligence to a subject (combined with a lot of money), stuff happens and it tends to happen more quickly than the turgid government agencies that (with bigger budgets) have been working in these fields for decades. As the article states, toilets had not seen meaningful innovation for centuries:

“Mr Gates considers it time for a change. On August 14th his charity, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, announced the gold-, silver- and bronze-medal winners in its Reinventing The Toilet Challenge, which aims to bring safe, affordable and ‘sustainable’ loos to the 40% of the world’s population who lack access to basic sanitation. This could help prevent many of the 1.5m childhood deaths from diarrhea that now occur each year.”

Following design, comes implementation:

“The Gates Foundation will now pay for prototypes to be tested in the field, probably of all three winners and possibly of some other ideas. Mr Gates hopes that the foundation’s reinvented toilets will start being deployed more widely in as little as two years. They will thus be able to help achieve what is the most off-track of the United Nations’ Millennium Development Goals: to halve by 2015 the proportion of people without sustainable access to basic sanitation.”

In most peoples’ point of view, Bill Gates usually fairs worse in comparison to Steve Jobs. The reason is that our understanding of ‘social value’ is warped. Steve Jobs was a brilliant businessman, but what Gates is doing with his Foundation is phenomenal.

Have a good weekend.
David


Instructor Teaching Site: http://www.sagepub.com/strategiccsr/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Flushed with pride
The Economist Technology Quarterly
The Economist
September 1, 2012
10

Monday, November 28, 2011

Strategic CSR - Toms Shoes

The article in the url below is a book review of an autobiography of Blake Mycoskie, the founder of Toms Shoes (http://www.toms.com/). Mycoskie’s innovation with Toms is the promise to donate one free pair of shoes to needy children for every pair of Toms shoes purchased (see also: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304252704575155903198032336.html). The autobiography is titled ‘Start Something That Matters’:

“In 2006, Blake Mycoskie, a Tiggerish Texan bounded off to Argentina on holiday. … While in Argentina he came across a shoe called the alpargata, a kind of espadrille, and thought it would sell well in the United States. On the same trip, he met an American woman who was running a shoe drive, to deliver shoes to poor Argentine children. Twang went his entrepreneurial synapses: "Why not create a for-profit business to help provide shoes for these children? Why not come up with a solution that guaranteed a constant flow of shoes, not just whenever kind people were able to make a donation?"”

Being The Wall Street Journal, the reviewer is skeptical of the “social entrepreneur” label Mycoskie uses throughout the book. The author’s skepticism generates a great point:

“Though General Electric builds power plants and life-saving medical equipment and Exxon heats homes in winter and keeps the world moving with its fuel, they are decried as the villains of society, while the "social" entrepreneurs are venerated for giving us hemp shirts and organic greens. It has never seemed a fair distinction.”

While recognizing the incontrovertible social value those firms have generated, Toms achievements are pretty impressive, too:

“[In 2010] the company reported that, with the help of charities and other groups, its giveaways had passed the million-pair mark.”

The advantage of a business model such as Toms (which now also includes eye glasses: http://www.toms.com/eyewear/), though, is that value is more likely to be added without the damage that the products of a traditional for-profit firm such as Exxon can also cause. The reviewer, ultimately, is also persuaded:

“Having given away a million pairs of shoes—to children who, when barefoot, might be vulnerable to hookworm, tetanus and other soil-borne ailments—buys Mr. Mycoskie the credibility he needs. I finished the book not only wanting to buy a pair of Toms but also wanting to "start something that matters" myself.”

The important insight worth building a business around?

“People yearn to do meaningful work.”

Wednesday, October 19, 2011

Strategic CSR - Social Entrepreneurship

The article in the url below highlights flaws in what it terms “the trendy field of social entrepreneurship”—the framing of developing world problems based on a Western perspective and then proposing out of context solutions without fully understanding the real-life complexities.

The article, in particular, focuses on a competition, initially proposed on Harvard Business Review’s website, to design a $300 home to alleviate housing needs in poorer parts of the world, such as in India’s slums:

“But one expert has been left out of the competition, even though her input would have saved much time and effort for those involved in conceiving the house: the person who is supposed to live in it.”

The article then goes on to outline why “the $300 house will fail,” explaining that many residents already have equity of up to $3,000 in their current properties and are unlikely to surrender that value, while importing ready-made constructions will disrupt the local employment of laborers, carpenters, plumbers, and so on. In short:

“The $300 house will fail as a social initiative because the dynamic needs, interests and aspirations of the millions of people who live in places like Dharavi have been overlooked. This kind of mistake is all too common in the trendy field of social entrepreneurship. While businessmen and professors applaud the $300 house, the urban poor are silent, busy building a future for themselves. ”

Monday, April 18, 2011

Strategic CSR - Porter & Kramer

By now, you will probably have read about Michael Porter and Mark Kramer’s latest foray into CSR—‘Creating Shared Value.’ If not, here is their front cover story of the first HBR issue of 2011, with accompanying video, humbly titled How to fix Capitalism—The Big Idea:


A pdf of the full article is available from HBR at:


Ultimately, the argument that Porter and Kramer are building (and this is now their third HBR CSR article, following on from ‘The Competitive Advantage of Corporate Philanthropy’ in 2002 and ‘Strategy & Society: The Link Between Competitive Advantage and Corporate Social Responsibility’ in 2006) is that firms should identify issues containing both economic and social goals, and then utilize their expertise to generate market-based solutions. In this way, both economic value and social value are maximized.

The reaction of the CSR community has been to point out that, while they are very welcome to join the party and can do much to push CSR up the agenda of many unpersuaded CEOs, they are late and somewhat behind the times:

http://tobiaswebb.blogspot.com/2011/01/does-michael-porter-understand.html

The idea Porter and Kramer present, as I understand it, is similar to Bill Gates and Muhammad Yunus’ work on “caring capitalism”—essentially a re-branding of the ideas behind social entrepreneurship (Issues: Social Entrepreneurship, p189). My criticism of the idea, therefore, is the same—that, while the idea sounds good in theory, in reality, the potential reach of this business model is limited. A good example is Product (RED) (Case-studies: Product (RED), p352), which is very successful as a cause-related business, but has fallen well short of the game-changing solution its founders were hoping for.

What I find funny about the new Porter/Kramer article is where they lay the blame for the current myopic view of business, without the slightest hint of irony:

“In understanding the business environment, managers have focused most of their attention on the industry, or the particular business in which the firm competes. … Companies have failed to grasp the importance of the broader business environment surrounding their major operations.”

Now, I wonder whose ideas and models taught widely in business schools would have encouraged managers to focus “most of their attention on the industry, or the particular business in which the firm competes”……..???

What we argue in Strategic CSR is that firms should focus on identifying problems for which there is a clear market-based solution and then deliver that solution in an efficient and socially responsible manner. The idea of CSR as an integrated component of strategy focuses on firms’ areas of expertise throughout all aspects of operations, but de-emphasizes actions that stray outside a firm’s areas of expertise for which there either may not be a market solution, or the firm is not well-suited to deliver. That is how long term shareholder value is maximized—by operating in a way that seeks to meet the needs and demands of the firm’s stakeholders, broadly defined. In other words, the focus of business remains the same; it is the way you go about it that is different with a CSR perspective.

Porter and Kramer, however, want to change the focus. As they put it in their introduction:

“The purpose of the corporation must be redefined as creating shared value, not just profit per se.”

In some instances, these two perspectives (caring capitalism and strategic CSR) will produce the same behavior, but the motivating force is different and this is important because it will ultimately lead to different outcomes in terms of the success or failure of the venture. For example, Starbucks should not form partnerships with shade-grown coffee farmers in Guatemala because they recognize those farmers face an uncertain future and there is an insufficient welfare net in place to support them if they go out of business (a social goal), but because Starbucks needs to secure a stable supply of high quality coffee beans and supporting these farmers in a sustainable manner is the best way to guarantee that supply (an economic goal). In other words, Starbucks should form stable and lasting partnerships with these key suppliers not because they are seeking to fill a social need, they should do it because these farmers produce a raw material that is essential to their business. As such, Starbucks is incentivized to protect that raw material in a sustainable way, rather than ruthlessly exploit it. If those Guatemalan farmers are not producing a product that is in demand (i.e., if the business logic is not there), the argument that Starbucks should get involved is difficult to make.

Ultimately, although for-profit firms can help with the first perspective (caring capitalism), they are much better suited to the second perspective (market capitalism). Ideally, it is the role of effective governmental and nonprofit sectors to focus on those areas that the market ignores or cannot solve. In contrast, Porter and Kramer argue that social goals should be considered equally with economic goals and firms should then utilize their market-based skills and expertise to solve that problem—In other words, that they should become less like for-profit firms and more like social entrepreneurs, government agencies, or nonprofit organizations. While well-intentioned, I believe that this is not an effective plan for “how to fix capitalism” and, instead, is a misunderstanding of the value of for-profit firms in our society (and of the role that a CSR perspective brings in maximizing that value). As argued in the article in the url below:

“In her 2009 book SuperCorp, … Rosabeth Moss Kanter warned of the pitfalls for companies that make "social commitments that do not have an economic logic that sustains the enterprise by attracting resources". More companies are learning to reap commercial benefits from strategies that have a wider social value. That's great. But the basic job of coaxing capitalism in the right direction is the same as it always has been: find ways to harness society's needs to companies' self-interest and hope the two stay together.”

Take care
David


Instructor Teaching Site: http://www.sagepub.com/strategiccsr/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Society and the right kind of capitalism
Hill, Andrew
724 words
22 February 2011
Financial Times
London Ed1
14
or

Wednesday, December 1, 2010

Strategic CSR - Caring Capitalism

The article in the url below focuses on the growing wealth of successful Indian entrepreneurs (such as Vinod Khosla, “the billionaire venture capitalist and co-founder of Sun Microsystems”) and their willingness to invest it in philanthropic enterprises. One quote, in particular, from the article stood out:

“Mr. Khosla said his experience with microfinance had helped shape his views on the best way to tackle poverty. He has invested in commercial microfinance lenders and has donated to nonprofit ones, and he said that moneymaking versions had grown much faster and reached many more needy borrowers.”

The article and the philosophy behind the quote draws heavily on the Bottom-of-the-Pyramid (BOP) work of C.K. Prahalad (Issues: Profit, p271):

“By backing businesses that provide education loans or distribute solar panels in villages, he says, he wants to show that commercial entities can better help people in poverty than most nonprofit charitable organizations.”

While there is certainly an important role for social entrepreneurs in CSR (Issues: Social Entrepreneurship, p189), however, I think it is overly optimistic to think businesses should exist primarily to solve social problems.

Business is the solution to market problems/opportunities that carry social value as a consequence. Firms maximize social value by combining scarce and valuable resources to meet market needs, while considering the interests of a broad range of stakeholders and planning to maximize sustainable shareholder returns over the long term. Firms can often use their expertise to aid in meeting social goals, but this should not be their primary concern. Governments and nonprofits also play important social roles where gaps in the market occur.

The danger in using for-profit organizations primarily to solve social problems is that the profit motive can easily corrupt the founding purpose. This is becoming increasingly evident in the microfinance industry (see Strategic CSR – Microfinance, September 27, 2010, below) in which the article reports that Khosla has just profited “about $117 million” from SKS Microfinance’s recent IPO (see also, more recently, Strategic CSR – Microfinance, November 22, 2010).

Take care
David


Instructor Teaching Site: http://www.sagepub.com/strategiccsr/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


In Capitalism, Sun's Co-Founder Sees a Pathway to Help the Poor
By VIKAS BAJAJ
1287 words
6 October 2010
The New York Times
Late Edition - Final
1


From: David Chandler {msbbe096}
Sent: Monday, September 27, 2010 11:45 AM
Subject: Strategic CSR - Microfinance

The article in the url below suggests the dangers of success for the microfinance business model (Issues: Microfinance, p245):

“SKS Microfinance, India's largest lender to the poor, aims to raise about $350m this month by selling a 21.6 per cent stake in an initial public offering expected to spark a wave of listings by equity-strapped Indian microfinance companies.”

While the high rates of repayment and community structure present a real opportunity for microfinance institutions to be profitable (or at least self-sustaining), the profit-maximization pressures (higher interest rates and lower loan qualification standards) that accompany a public listing carry the potential to undermine the social-entrepreneurship microfinance goals (Issues: Social Entrepreneurship, p189):

“Muhammad Yunus, the Nobel Peace Prize-winning founder of Bangladesh's Grameen Bank - the world's most famous microlender - has criticised the commercialisation of the industry, saying profit-oriented microlenders are little different to the loan sharks they once set out to replace.”

The possibility for corruption quickly arises as the pursuit of profit spreads across the sub-units of the organization:

“SKS, which says it has 7m borrowers in 19 Indian States, also plans to boost its revenues through alliances with large companies to distribute their products - such as mobile phones and water purifiers - even as it provides rural consumers with the microloans needed to buy the items.”

The article in the second url below shows the success and rapid growth of microfinance organizations, such as SKS, in India:

“For the last three years, outstanding loan portfolios of Indian micro-finance institutions have grown by 65 per cent annually, according to the World Bank, with total loans of about $2.5bn to about 22.6m households.”

As well as reinforcing the threats:

“Typical loans average between $200 and $250, and carry rates of about 28 per cent - lower than money-lenders, albeit still expensive when compared with commercial bank rates.”

Take care
David


Instructor Teaching Site: http://www.sagepub.com/strategiccsr/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


SKS Microfinance plans to raise $350m in IPO
By James Fontanella-Khan in Mumbai and Amy Kazmin in New Delhi
418 words
21 July 2010
Financial Times
Asia Ed1
17

New networks help ease debt dilemma
Kazmin, Amy
603 words
21 July 2010
Financial Times
Asia Ed1
17

Friday, October 15, 2010

Strategic CSR - Social Entrepreneurship

The article in the url below outlines the competition between three nonprofit groups to supply low cost eye glasses to the world’s poor:

“Hundreds of millions of people -- some put the estimates as high as two billion -- do not have the corrective lenses that would allow them to lead better, more productive lives. … Though these adjustable glasses cannot yet help with conditions like astigmatism, at least 80 percent of refractive errors can be fixed.”
The technology developed by the three groups (one in the UK and two in the Netherlands) revolves around self-correcting lenses, which allow the user to adjust the focus themselves, removing the need for a trained technician:

“[The UK design, called Adspecs, http://www.vdw.ox.ac.uk/2minuteintro.htm, allows for] the corrective power of the glasses to be adjusted by means of a clear fluid injected into the lenses. … [The competing] Dutch models are based on a design pioneered in the 1960s by Luis W. Alvarez, an American who won a Nobel Prize in physics. The design uses two lenses that slide across each other to alter their focus.”
Each of the technologies has its pros and cons, and none of the groups is yet in a position to meet its goals of widespread circulation:

“When it comes to choosing sides, many of the charitable groups involved say they are open to whatever glasses do the job. J. Kevin White, a former Marine who runs Global Vision 2020, a foundation that distributes adjustable glasses, said fluid-filled lenses generally offer better optical quality and correct a greater range of refractive error. The Alvarez designs, by contrast, are cheaper, smaller, better-looking and less likely to break.”
Have a good weekend.
David

Bill Werther & David Chandler
Strategic Corporate Social Responsibility: Stakeholders in a Global Environment (2e)
© Sage Publications, 2011
http://www.sagepub.com/strategiccsr2e/

Instructor Teaching Site: http://www.sagepub.com/strategiccsr/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Better Vision For the World, On a Budget
By DOUGLAS HEINGARTNER
1312 words
2 January 2010
The New York Times
Late Edition - Final
1
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/02/business/global/02glasses.html

Monday, September 27, 2010

Strategic CSR - Microfinance

The article in the url below suggests the dangers of success for the microfinance business model (Issues: Microfinance, p245):

“SKS Microfinance, India's largest lender to the poor, aims to raise about $350m this month by selling a 21.6 per cent stake in an initial public offering expected to spark a wave of listings by equity-strapped Indian microfinance companies.”
While the high rates of repayment and community structure present a real opportunity for microfinance institutions to be profitable (or at least self-sustaining), the profit-maximization pressures (higher interest rates and lower loan qualification standards) that accompany a public listing carry the potential to undermine the social-entrepreneurship microfinance goals (Issues: Social Entrepreneurship, p189):

“Muhammad Yunus, the Nobel Peace Prize-winning founder of Bangladesh's Grameen Bank - the world's most famous microlender - has criticised the commercialisation of the industry, saying profit-oriented microlenders are little different to the loan sharks they once set out to replace.”
The possibility for corruption quickly arises as the pursuit of profit spreads across the sub-units of the organization:

“SKS, which says it has 7m borrowers in 19 Indian States, also plans to boost its revenues through alliances with large companies to distribute their products - such as mobile phones and water purifiers - even as it provides rural consumers with the microloans needed to buy the items.”
The article in the second url below shows the success and rapid growth of microfinance organizations, such as SKS, in India:

“For the last three years, outstanding loan portfolios of Indian micro-finance institutions have grown by 65 per cent annually, according to the World Bank, with total loans of about $2.5bn to about 22.6m households.”
As well as reinforcing the threats:

“Typical loans average between $200 and $250, and carry rates of about 28 per cent - lower than money-lenders, albeit still expensive when compared with commercial bank rates.”
Take care
David

Bill Werther & David Chandler
Strategic Corporate Social Responsibility: Stakeholders in a Global Environment (2e)
© Sage Publications, 2011
http://www.sagepub.com/strategiccsr2e/

Instructor Teaching Site: http://www.sagepub.com/strategiccsr/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


SKS Microfinance plans to raise $350m in IPO
By James Fontanella-Khan in Mumbai and Amy Kazmin in New Delhi
418 words
21 July 2010
Financial Times
Asia Ed1
17
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/1879f6e4-9422-11df-a3fe-00144feab49a.html

New networks help ease debt dilemma
Kazmin, Amy
603 words
21 July 2010
Financial Times
Asia Ed1
17
http://presscuttings.ft.com/presscuttings/s/3/viewPdf/37730595