The CSR Newsletters are a freely-available resource generated as a dynamic complement to the textbook, Strategic Corporate Social Responsibility: Sustainable Value Creation.

To sign-up to receive the CSR Newsletters regularly during the fall and spring academic semesters, e-mail author David Chandler at david.chandler@ucdenver.edu.

Showing posts with label Coca-cola. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Coca-cola. Show all posts

Thursday, October 16, 2025

Strategic CSR - Paper straws

The trouble with plastic is that it is really useful and really cheap, which means it is very difficult to replace:

"Most plastic alternatives have an element 'that doesn't work very well, or isn't biodegradable, or it could just be way too expensive,' said Dillon Baxter, chief executive of PlantSwitch, which uses rice husks—the sheath that protects a rice kernel—for its plastic replacement. 'If you're a company that wants to do the right thing, it's pretty hard' to find a workable option, he said."

The work of PlantSwitch, which is featured in the article in the url below, makes clear that replacements are challenging. This is true along multiple dimensions, but cost is preeminent:

"The issue is that effective sustainable plastic replacements are still few and far between, and cost a lot more than their counterparts derived from fossil fuels. … Dallas-based PlantSwitch, for example, makes substitutes for plastic straws, containers, cutlery, plates and bowls. It does so by blending the husks with a bio-based polymer synthesized by microorganisms to create a resin that can be molded into the final product. An ordinary plastic straw costs around 0.7 cents, while the PlantSwitch version is 1.4 cents, the company said."

Fortunately, the legal context is shifting, which should incentivize companies to come up with an effective solution more quickly than they otherwise might:

"Meanwhile, businesses are bracing to meet new requirements including a packaging waste directive in the European Union. The rule will require all packaging to be recyclable, among other things. In the U.S., some states are adopting laws intended to make manufacturers financially responsible for where plastic ends up, but overall the country has taken a lighter touch."

Customers provide an even bigger incentive, which I would argue is the more important driver of lasting change:

"… some companies are opting for alternative materials to meet the demand of consumers seeking nonplastic options. A July survey from sustainability consulting firm Aura found that more shoppers in the U.S., Canada and Europe are eschewing certain products if the packaging doesn't seem sustainable. … Aside from concerns about pollution, consumers are increasingly unnerved by the impact plastic and tiny microplastic particles have on human health."

But, in order for customers to shift, efficacy is essential:

"The right packaging depends on what product it is supposed to be protecting. 'Cucumber wrapped in plastic extends the shelf life, so why wouldn't you do that?' said Ken Bowles, chief financial officer at Dublin-based sustainable packaging company Smurfit Westrock. 'But if you're using [corrugated board] for strawberries or raspberries, there's no impact on shelf life.'"

In essence:

 

"A nonplastic product has to be just as functional as plastic to catch on. Plastic producers say the material is essential for modern life, and other options can pale in comparison."


Given the challenges (which includes the overall economic context), companies are walking back some of their public sustainability commitments:


"Gartner said in a late July report that 75% of organizations with sustainable-packaging targets will roll them back, and look instead to comply with coming legislative guidelines. Coca-Cola faced criticism in December when it walked back a commitment to make 25% of its products with reusable packaging by 2030. The company also said it may be more reliant on plastic following tariffs on aluminum."


Take care

David


David Chandler

Strategic Corporate Social Responsibility: Sustainable Value Creation (6e)

© Sage Publications, 2023


Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: https://study.sagepub.com/chandler6e  

Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/

The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/



Alternative Materials to Plastic Struggle to Get Off the Ground

By Clara Hudson

August 12, 2025

The Wall Street Journal

Late Edition – Final

B2

https://www.wsj.com/articles/plastic-waste-is-piling-up-but-alternative-materials-struggle-to-get-off-the-ground-f53bc6e3

 

Tuesday, November 12, 2024

Strategic CSR - Goalposts

What to do when you face the likelihood you will fail to reach a goal you set yourself only a short while ago? Well, you move the goalposts, of course. Or, at least, that is what you do if you are a large corporation that is having second thoughts about your public commitment to reduce plastic waste, as indicated in the article in the url below:

"In 2020, dozens of major companies joined the U.S. Plastics Pact, signaling a commitment to minimizing plastic waste. Their goals included phasing out plastic straws, cutlery and intentionally-added PFAS, also known as "forever chemicals"; recycling or composting half of their plastic packaging; and making sure 100% of plastic packaging would be reusable, recyclable or compostable—all by 2025."

After all, the companies that signed this pledge are responsible for up to a third of all plastic waste in the U.S.:

"Signatories include major brands like General Mills, NestlĂ©, Kraft Heinz and Coca-Cola Co., the largest known contributor to global branded plastic waste, according to research published in the journal Science Advances. Retailers like Walmart and Target and packaging and materials suppliers also signed."

While all the companies have reiterated their commitment to reducing plastic waste, of course, the targets will need to wait a little longer:

"Now, with the 2025 deadline close at hand, the U.S. Plastics Pact has published an updated set of objectives. They look a lot like the 2020 goals, with a key difference: Many of the target dates have been pushed back to 2030."

OK, so one reconsideration is understandable. After all, this is difficult stuff, right?

"It is not the first time companies have pushed back timelines for aggressive recycling targets. Coca-Cola and NestlĂ© both made public promises as far back as 2007 and 2008 that didn't come to fruition, according to the Conservation Law Foundation, an environmental advocacy group."

As always, it is easy to find reasons why we cannot make the progress we need to make. Ultimately, though, we either make the changes we need to, or we do not:

"Today, less than 10% of plastic waste in the U.S. is recycled annually, according to a 2023 report from the National Academy of Sciences. While companies frequently tout pilot projects for plant-based plastics or paper bottles, the problem is expected to get worse in the future. Recent projections have found that plastic waste could triple by 2060, according to the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development."

Take care
David

David Chandler
© Sage Publications, 2023

Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: https://study.sagepub.com/chandler6e 
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Companies Push Back Plastic-Waste Goals
By H. Claire Brown
June 11, 2024
The Wall Street Journal
Late Edition – Final
B10
 

Tuesday, February 13, 2024

Strategic CSR - ESG

The article in the url below updates a newsletter I sent in September about how executives, in the face of growing ideological polarization around ESG-related issues, are engaging in "green-hushing" by mentioning ESG less often on quarterly calls (see Strategic CSR – Green-hushing):

"Many companies no longer utter these three letters: E-S-G. Following years of simmering investor backlash, political pressure and legal threats over environmental, social and governance efforts, a number of business leaders are now making a conscious effort to avoid the once widely used acronym for such initiatives."

Instead:

"On earnings calls, many chief executives now employ new approaches. Some companies, including Coca-Cola, are rebranding corporate reports and committees, stripping ESG from titles. Advisers are coaching executives on alternative ways to describe their efforts, proposing new terms like 'responsible business.' On Wall Street, meanwhile, some firms are closing once-popular ESG funds as interest fades."

The chart accompanying the article, illustrating the number of S&P 500 firms that refer directly to "ESG" in their quarterly earnings calls, is instructive:


This pattern is replicated within firms, also, including some of the most high-profile advocates for ESG. For example, I saw this chart recently from Bloomberg about Larry Fink's BlackRock:
 

And, even more dire, in New Hampshire (and a few other U.S. states), the Republican-led legislature has tried to criminalize ESG investing:

"Republican lawmakers in New Hampshire are seeking to make using ESG criteria in state funds a crime in the latest attack on the beleaguered investing strategy."

My own reaction to this is that the pushback against the ESG 'industry' is justified, but is being motivated by the wrong reasons. Although the partisan rhetoric can be wildly misleading, the lack of consistent definitions and measurements, let alone agreement on what even should be measured, means the ESG industry only has itself to blame (see Strategic CSR – ESG). Moreover, the focus has been almost exclusively on the "E," with little discussion around the huge (and equally essential) areas of the "S" and the "G," which few people understand and even fewer know how to measure. The emergence (and advocacy) of ESG, although no doubt due to good intentions, has been a mess and has set-back the cause as a whole. Because it was so poorly thought-through, the opening was created for those with an ideological agenda (or even for those who just care to exploit the information asymmetry to make money) to wade in, and the result has been both ugly and extremely unhelpful.

Take care
David

David Chandler
© Sage Publications, 2023

Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: https://study.sagepub.com/chandler6e 
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Companies Avoid Mentioning ESG, The Latest No-No
By Chip Cutter and Emily Glazer
January 10, 2024
The Wall Street Journal
Late Edition – Final
A1, A6

Friday, September 22, 2023

Strategic CSR - Oatly

I saw this ad in main section of The Sunday New York Times on May 7 (pp.18-19), earlier this year:


Several thoughts on this (and Oatly, which I featured favorably in a prior newsletter; see Strategic CSR – Oatly):

First, Tropicana was one of the earliest brands to calculate the carbon footprint of their orange juice, more than 10 years ago (see Strategic CSR – PepsiCo). What is interesting is that, at that time, I recall they did not advertise the number – the wanted the knowledge primarily to improve their operating/supply chain efficiency. But, if marketing is central to the effort, as it obviously is for Oatly, then there are two questions that are essential – how accurate is the number (are they counting everything that needs to be counted; there are real issues with scope 3 emissions, let along scope 4 – see Strategic CSR – Scope 4 emissions) and does anyone understand it? It will not cause any change in behavior unless customers understand what that number means and can compare it to competing products (the absence of consistent numbers across companies and industries is why all the ESG stuff has been essentially meaningless, so far; see Strategic CSR – ESG).

Second, Oatly is not as good a product as I originally thought. It tastes great, but the reason is that it is stuffed full of sugar. My doctor told me the golden rule is that the amount of protein needs to be greater than the amount of sugar, and I think in Oatly it is the same, 5g of both (if I am remembering the numbers correctly). Fairlife (a Coke product) is much better on this metric – lactose free and much more protein than sugar.

So, the danger with so many of these initiatives at present (because there is no standardization) is that Oatly draws consumers' attention to this work that they are doing (which is no doubt well-intentioned, but may or may not be meaningful – really hard to know without a lot of digging) as a way of concealing the fact that their product is not that much different than drinking a can of soda.

For more information on some of Oatly's progressive approach to this issue, see: https://www.oatly.com/en-us/stuff-we-sell/climate-footprint

Take care
David

David Chandler
© Sage Publications, 2023

Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: https://study.sagepub.com/chandler6e 
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/

Thursday, April 20, 2023

Strategic CSR - Bill Nye

For those of you in the U.S. who grew up learning about science from Bill Nye, I have a couple of videos for you that reflect his (public) position on climate change. There is the optimistic Bill Nye, who has been contracted by Coca-Cola to sell the idea that we are just around the corner from a perfect solution to the problem of waste:


This video/ad was reviewed in the article in the url below, with the author denouncing the relationship as a pretty straightforward incidence of greenwashing:

"Bad news for everyone who loved watching Bill Nye the Science Guy during middle school science class: your fave is problematic. This week, Coca-Cola, one of the world's biggest plastic polluters, teamed up with TV's favorite scientist for a campaign to create a 'world without waste,' a joke of a corporate greenwashing campaign."

Needless to say, the assessment of the author is that Bill is, at best, presenting a highly selective element of a much more complicated issue:

"The video is, on the surface, an accurate depiction of the process of recycling a beverage bottle. The problem lies in what recycling can actually do. … Most of those plastics can only be reused once or twice before ending up in a landfill. Nye, for all his talk of science on TV, should know this. Over recycling's 60-year history, less than 10% of plastic that has been produced has ever been recycled. And while in theory, PET—the type of plastic that makes bottles—can be recycled more times than other types of plastic, that's not usually what happens. Virgin plastic is, simply put, cheaper to make into things like bottles than recycled plastic. Less than 30% of plastic bottles are recycled in the U.S., and a lot of that stock is turned not into other bottles, but 'downcycled' into other things, like filler and fabric. These products, in turn, can't be recycled again. The plastic ends up in landfills."

Then, there is the more attention-grabbing (and realistic) assessment of the situation in a short video Bill recorded as part of a John Oliver segment on climate change:


I am guessing that the John Oliver video did not pay nearly as well as the Coca-Cola video, and I'll leave you to determine which one you think is the message we need to be sending from one of the most respected public voices on science.

Take care
David

David Chandler
© Sage Publications, 2023

Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: https://study.sagepub.com/chandler6e 
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Bill Nye, the Sellout Guy
By Molly Taft
April 7, 2022
Gizmodo
 

Thursday, October 28, 2021

Strategic CSR - Recycling

The article in the url below contains some rare positive news on the recycling front. Specifically, it reports on a Maine law, passed over the summer, that seeks to shift the cost of recycling to the companies that produce the packaging:

"Recycling … was a headache for municipal governments even in good times. And, only a small amount was actually getting recycled. Then, five years ago, China stopped buying most of America's recycling, and dozens of cities across the United States suspended or weakened their recycling programs. Now, Maine has implemented a new law that could transform the way packaging is recycled by requiring manufacturers, rather than taxpayers, to cover the cost. Nearly a dozen states have been considering similar regulations and Oregon is about to sign its own version in coming weeks."

The difference is where the burden for funding the recycling lies – not on the commodities market, as previously, but on the firms that previously benefited from the externalized costs of cleaning up the packaging they created:

"Essentially, these programs work by charging producers a fee based on a number of factors, including the tonnage of packaging they put on the market. Those fees are typically paid into a producer responsibility organization, a nonprofit group contracted and audited by the state. It reimburses municipal governments for their recycling operations with the fees collected from producers."

Although these laws are potentially ground-breaking in the U.S., they are not new, or even particularly innovative, when you consider where other countries are on this issue. What they are, however, is effective:

"Nearly all European Union member states, as well as Japan, South Korea and five Canadian provinces, have laws like these and they have seen their recycling rates soar and their collection programs remain resilient. … Ireland's recycling rate for plastics and paper products, for instance, rose from 19 percent in 2000 to 65 percent in 2017. Nearly every E.U. country with such programs has a recycling rate between 60 and 80 percent, according to an analysis by the Product Stewardship Institute. In 2018, the most recent year for which data is available, America's recycling rate was 32 percent, a decline from a few years earlier."

Of course, that does not mean they are popular with the firms that are now being expected to clean up the mess they have been making:

"In Maine, the packaging industry supported a competing bill that would have given producers more oversight of the program. It also would have exempted packaging for a range of pharmaceutical products and hazardous substances, including paint thinners, antifreeze and household cleaning products. One of the industry's main objections to the bill that ultimately passed was that it gave the government too much authority and left the industry with not enough voice in the process."

No doubt, the authors of the bill might have noted that this was the whole point of the exercise, since self-regulation has clearly not been sufficient to produce meaningful action:

"There are concerns that a growing market for plastics could drive demand for oil, contributing to the release of greenhouse gas emissions precisely at a time when the world needs to drastically cut emissions. By 2050, the plastics industry is expected to consume 20 percent of all the oil produced. The oil industry, concerned about declining demand as the world moves toward electric cars and away from fossil fuels, has pivoted toward making more plastic — spending more than $200 billion on chemical and plastic manufacturing plants in the United States. Vast amounts of plastic waste are exported to Africa and South Asia, where they often end up in dumps or in waterways and oceans."


The result is what has become known as extended producer responsibility (EPR) programs for packaging products, and they can be extensive:

 

"In Maine, packaging products covered by the law make up as much as 40 percent of the waste stream. … [Maine is] requiring producers to cover 100 percent of its municipalities' recycling costs. Oregon, by contrast, will require producers to cover around 28 percent of the costs of recycling, with municipalities continuing to cover the rest."


And, encouragingly, some companies are seeing these legislative efforts as an opportunity to innovate, whereas previously they might have resisted or simply passed on the additional costs to customers:


"Some major consumer-product companies have begun voicing support for policies like these. In 2016, Greenpeace obtained internal documents from Coca-Cola Europe, which depicted extended producer responsibility as a policy that the company was fighting. In a sign of change, this spring, more than 100 multinational companies, including Coca-Cola, Unilever, and Walmart, signed a pledge committing to support E.P.R. policies."


Take care

David


David Chandler

Strategic Corporate Social Responsibility: Sustainable Value Creation (5e)

© Sage Publications, 2020


Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: https://study.sagepub.com/chandler5e 

Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/

The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/



Maine Law Could Help Revive Recycling

By Winston Choi-Schagrin

July 23, 2021

The New York Times

Late Edition – Final

B1, B3

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/21/climate/maine-recycling-law-EPR.html

 

Tuesday, September 7, 2021

Strategic CSR - Gender bias

The article in the url makes the case that gender association with firms affects consumer perceptions of those organizations:

"The study, recently published in the Journal of Marketing, finds feminine-sounding brands may be more appealing, because they are often perceived as warmer and thereby associated with traits like trustworthiness, sincerity, friendliness, tolerance and good nature."

The researchers were able to isolate specific variables that predict whether a consumer perceives a brand to be either more masculine or more feminine:

"Women's names, for instance, are longer, and are more likely to end in a vowel sound. In one part of the paper researchers studied how participants reacted to two fictitious brand names—one with feminine linguistic characters and the other with male linguistic characteristics—and found participants often preferred feminine brand names."

The benefit for firms is that the researchers found consumers are more likely to select products associated with feminine brands:

"Participants were 34% more likely to choose a female-named Nimilia YouTube channel than a masculine-named Nimeld YouTube channel. Participants were also three times as likely to choose a Nimilia hand sanitizer than a Nimeld hand sanitizer."

In addition to those made-up names, the researchers applied the same approach to ask consumer perceptions about existing brands:

"The researchers … looked at an index created by the marketing and consulting firm Interbrand, and found 55% of its top brands, including Coca-Cola, Honda and IKEA, had feminine names, 36% of the brands had masculine-sounding names, and 9% of the brands had gender-neutral names."

Take care
David

David Chandler
© Sage Publications, 2020

Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: https://study.sagepub.com/chandler5e 
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


When a Brand Sounds Feminine, Consumers Get a Warm Feeling
By Lisa Ward
May 24, 2021
The Wall Street Journal
Late Edition – Final
R9
 

Thursday, April 22, 2021

Strategic CSR - Personhood and politics

An issue that has surfaced for me in my classes this semester, particularly when discussing the challenges firms face in deciding their position on controversial issues such as the new Georgia voting laws, is the extent to which firms should be proactive or reactive in the actions they take. As indicated in the article in the url below, firms are increasingly finding themselves caught in a ratcheting of expectations – the more they engage in such issues, the more they are expected to do so:

"Civil-rights activists pressured Delta and Coca-Cola to take public stands against the law, which the groups have called restrictive and racist. Some of the companies' own employees echoed those concerns. After an initially muted public response, CEOs at both companies, which said they had been lobbying lawmakers behind the scenes, ultimately spoke out against the law."

But by waiting, the article argues, the firms end up pleasing no one and annoying everyone:

"In the end, their statements came too late to please many activists on the left and angered many on the right. Georgia House members voted to revoke a tax break for Delta, though the effort didn't go farther before the legislature adjourned last week. Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell accused big businesses of 'behaving like a woke parallel government,' and threatened 'serious consequences' for companies, though he later tempered his stance. The companies found themselves in the strange position of facing boycott calls from critics on both sides."

The more I thought about this, however, the more I realized that this might simply be another mistaken attempt to anthropomorphize large organizations (something the mainstream discussion around CSR does as a way to deflect blame from the real source of any problems they see – people). It seems to me that traits we might see as unprincipled in individuals might actually be a strength in corporations. In other words, another way to think about firms that wait to see which way the wind is blowing before issuing strong public statements on a particular issue is that they are waiting to see which issues their key stakeholders clearly care about. The article focuses on how customers react to such issues:

"According to a 2020 survey of 8,000 consumers by public-relations giant Edelman, about 63% said they choose, switch to, avoid, or boycott a brand based on its stand on social issues. And in a more recent Edelman poll of 33,000 consumers, 86% said they expect CEOs to publicly speak out on social issues, while 68% said companies should step in when the government fails to fix social ills."

But, there are two problems with thinking through this challenge only from the perspective of customers. First, it is unwise to rely on a survey to understand how people will really act and, second, there are many other stakeholders than customers to consider. Instead, if firms were to proactively determine their stance before an issue becomes part of the social discourse (an issue of principle that we might admire in an individual), the set of stakeholders who are able to participate in the decision is narrowed to the executives (and possibly the board). Since firms are non-agentic entities and it is only people who can act, in order for the firm to decide what to do ahead of time the firm's executives will need to decide on its behalf. This means potentially that a narrow set of interests/values/morals, etc. are represented in the decision that is announced. By waiting, however, the firm is effectively expanding the set of stakeholders who weigh in on an issue, determine it is important, and signal to the firm how they want it to respond.

This is not to diminish the value of a strong, values-based culture that can unite the firm and its stakeholders in achieving the firm's purpose. But, in particular on issues that can be so far removed from core operations and areas of expertise (like voting laws), it might pay firms to wait and see, instead of issuing premature statements that represent what the firm's executives think they should say/do, rather than what their stakeholders as a whole want them to say/do.

The key in all cases, of course, whether proactive or reactive, is that the firm is genuine in its intentions, and not just issuing a statement designed to appease stakeholders without committing to substantive action.

Take care
David

David Chandler
© Sage Publications, 2020

Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: https://study.sagepub.com/chandler5e 
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


The New Business of Business is … Politics
By Chip Cutter, Suzanne Vranica, and Alison Sider
April 10-11, 2021
The Wall Street Journal
Late Edition – Final
B1, B9

Thursday, November 14, 2019

Strategic CSR - Plastic (II)

The article in the url below charts a rise in the cost of recycled plastics:
 
"In recent months, the price of recycled plastic flakes, used to make goods from soft drink bottles to glitter, has become more expensive than virgin plastic for the first time. For years the cost of making plastic products from recycled flakes was cheaper than relying on virgin plastics made using fossil fuels, meaning the sustainable option was an economic option too. But according to experts it is now cheaper for major manufacturers to use new plastic. A report from S&P Global Platts, a commodity market specialist, revealed that recycled plastic now costs an extra $72 (£57) a tonne compared with newly made plastic."
 
This higher price is reportedly due to increased interest among manufacturers who want to include recycled materials in their packaging so that they can advertise that fact to consumers:
 
"Coca-Cola's European business plans to cut the amount of virgin plastic used in its soft drink bottles to 50% within the next two years, and will change the colour of its Sprite bottles from green to clear to make sure 100% of its bottles can be reused."
 
In addition:
 
"… new plastic is becoming cheaper to make due to a flood of petrochemicals production from the US driven by the shale gas boom. … this could cost sustainable manufacturers across Europe an extra $250m a year."
 
As a result, the article reports that the recycled industry is in trouble because it is now simply cheaper for manufacturers to use virgin plastic, at least for the moment:
 
"The UK is planning to tax companies which don't use at least 30% recycled plastic in their products, but until then it may be cheaper for companies to demand more new plastic to make their packaging."
 
This is confusing, to say the least. Ever since China stopped taking waste material from the West, I have been reading reports about how the recycling industry is in dire straits because the market value for recycled material is weak, leading to low prices, which mean it is not economically worthwhile for waste collectors to collect recycled materials and process them. Now, the article in the url below reports such materials are becoming too high in demand, leading to sky high prices, meaning that manufacturers will likely switch to virgin materials. In other words, when the price of recycled materials is too low, it is not viable to collect and process the waste; when the price is too high, industry will simply switch to virgin materials. So when, exactly, will it become economically viable to recycle plastic? It seems that when we have too few recycled materials it doesn't make sense, and when we have too much of the stuff it doesn't make sense, either.
 
Take care
David
David Chandler
© Sage Publications, 2020
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: https://study.sagepub.com/chandler5e 
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


War on plastic waste faces setback as cost of recycled material soars
By Jillian Ambrose
October 13, 2019
The Guardian
 

Tuesday, October 8, 2019

Strategic CSR - Warren Buffett

I am not normally a fan of Warren Buffett as I think many of the companies he invests in (e.g., Wells Fargo, Coca-Cola, Kraft/Heinz, Dairy Queen, See's Candies, etc., etc.) and even the companies he partners with (e.g., 3G Capital) are hurting, rather than helping, society progress. I also think his investment decisions are luck as much as anything else, given his ill-judged support for CEO pay policies at Coke (that do not reflect performance), his strong support for the train company BNSF (when some 40% of rail freight in the U.S. is coal), or his aversion to investing in IT stock (he only got into Apple by mistake). All of this might somewhat explain why the WSJ recently noted that "Berkshire Hathaway Inc. has underperformed the S&P 500 for a decade … during a historic bull market." Like many executives that have run out of ideas, his main response appears to be to buy back his own firm's shares. But, that is not to say that the man has no idea what he is talking about. In the article in the url below, at least, he is on solid ground by proudly advocating in favor of capitalism:
 
"The most prominent face of capitalism — Warren Buffett, the avuncular founder of Berkshire and the fourth wealthiest person in the world, worth some $89 billion — appeared to distance himself from many of his peers, who have been apologizing for capitalism of late. 'I'm a card-carrying capitalist,' Mr. Buffett said. 'I believe we wouldn't be sitting here except for the market system,' he added, extolling the state of the economy. 'I don't think the country will go into socialism in 2020 or 2040 or 2060.'"
 
The author notes that this frank statement stands in contrast to some business leaders who profess statements on controversial issues that go with popular sentiment, only to quickly reverse their position when the spotlight has moved on:
 
"Some billionaires agonize about inequality and the education system, for example, but don't push for higher taxes on the wealthy to help pay for fixes (one of Mr. Buffett's preferred remedies). A raft of chief executives who boycotted going to Saudi Arabia after the murder of Jamal Khashoggi last year quickly returned to doing business with the kingdom when the headlines died down."
 
I am not convinced that Buffett thinks any more about the detail of advancing society than other business leaders—he is simply convinced that capitalism is the most direct way of getting there:
 
"… at his core, [Buffett] believes that the pursuit of capitalism is fundamentally moral — that it creates and produces prosperity and progress even when there are immoral actors and even when it creates inequality."
 
In this sense, he is following a strategic CSR perspective. In his investment decisions, however, he consistently veers off-track.
 
Take care
David
 
David Chandler
© Sage Publications, 2020
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://studysites.sagepub.comstudy.sagepub.com/chandler5e 
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/

Warren Buffett's Case for Capitalism

By Andrew Ross Sorkin
May 6, 2019
The New York Times
Late Edition – Final
B1
 

Wednesday, January 30, 2019

Strategic CSR - Super Bowl

The Super Bowl is taking place this weekend here in the US. In addition to the game itself, this event is known for the advertising that takes place during commercial breaks. Given the large potential captive audience, firms are willing to pay heavily for the chance to present to them and tradition dictates that they go all out. Often in previous years, the ads have been more eventful and entertaining than the game.
 
More recently, however, companies have begun to stray from product announcements and juvenile humor to tackle more difficult topics that the country is wrestling with at the time. One famous/infamous attempt (depending on your perspective) was Coca-Cola's ad for the 2014 Super Bowl, in which a very visibly diverse group of people (all of whom were US citizens) sang "America the Beautiful" in different languages (it still gives me goose bumps). See the 90 second version of the ad here, and some of the backlash/controversy it generated here.
 
Anyway, 2014 seems like a different age when we could be shocked by such 'controversial' acts. According to the article in the url below, we are now much more jaded and just want companies to stay away from such 'political' statements:
 
"More brands are capturing headlines by tangling with political and social issues in their advertising campaigns. A new poll suggests, however, that most Americans would rather they don't try the same thing during the Super Bowl. And viewers are likely to get what they want. Two-thirds of consumers call the Super Bowl an inappropriate place for advertisers to make political statements."
 
The graph in the article reports that, when asked if the Super Bowl is the "right platform for advertisers to make political statements," 2,200 respondents replied:
  • Very appropriate 7%
  • Somewhat appropriate 13%
  • Not too appropriate 17%
  • Not at all appropriate 49%
  • Don't know 14%

As might be expected, there are differences among generations, but even the youngest respondents were not keen on Super Bowl ads:
 
"Baby boomers in the poll disapproved of political Super Bowl advertisements more, at 77%, than younger cohorts such as millennials (55%) and Generation Z, defined as those 18-21 years old (43%). … Only 35% of Gen Z respondents to the poll called political Super Bowl ads "very" or "somewhat" appropriate."
 
This is a little strange, given that the mix of sport and politics was seeming to gain traction with Nike's support for Colin Kaepernick (see Strategic CSR – Patriotism and Strategic CSR - ESPN). The trouble is, I don't see how firms can avoid being 'political.' If they were to say we value our customers or our employees, I am guessing people would be OK with that, but it is no less of a political statement. I am sure there are issues that people would rather not be troubled with as they work their way through an unhealthy amount of chicken wings, but that is different from wanting firms to remove values from their advertising. Everything any firm does is grounded in ethics and values and morals—it is just that some firms judge the mood of the country better than other firms and get their ads 'right,' while others misjudge the mood and get their ads 'wrong.' What I like so much about the Coca-Cola ad is that the company knew it was putting something controversial out and it did it anyway. It felt the values were more important and they wanted to stand by them. It is why I love the ad so much. I wish more companies were as brave.
 
Enjoy the football for those of you in the US.
David
 
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: https://study.sagepub.com/chandler4e
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/
 
 
Consumers Say Brands Shouldn't Bring Politics to the Super Bowl
By Nat Ives
January 16, 2019
The Wall Street Journal
Late Edition – Final
 

Tuesday, September 25, 2018

Strategic CSR - Domino's Pizza

Years of reading and thinking about business (and CSR) have taught me that it is generally not a good idea for firms to over-estimate their customers. In spite of this, it happens frequently. A good example of this a few years ago was Coca-Cola's campaign to donate a percentage of sales to preserve the polar bear's habitat in the Artic. One problem – customers confused the white (= snow?) can selling regular Coke with the silver Diet Coke can. They also started reporting that the Coke tasted different. Coca-Cola, still traumatized by the New Coke fiasco in the 1980s, immediately withdrew all cans from sale and halted the campaign. The article in the url below reminded of the Coke polar bear incident. This time, Domino's Pizza launched a campaign in Russia promising pizza for life to anyone who had the firm's logo tattooed on their body. As The Wall Street Journal reports, Domino's clearly "underestimated how much Russians love free food."
 
"Bargains and freebies are powerful draws here. The Soviet period—where foodstuffs were often cheap but in short supply—and the economic hardships of the 1990s have conditioned many Russians to pounce on a good deal. A stagnant economy has left average disposable incomes stuck around $500 a month, and Ms. Koshkina [a customer 'who got a small Domino's logo tattooed above her left kneecap'] said the free pizza would help her put aside a bit of money from her salary working at a piercing and tattoo parlor. 'Who doesn't want free food?' she said."
 
Originally scheduled to last two months, Domino's suspended the campaign after only a few days as interest soared:
 
"A spokesman for Domino's Pizza Inc., the U.S.-based owner of the Domino's Pizza brand, said the Russian franchisee had been overwhelmed by the response, receiving more applicants in days than it had expected in months."
 
Again, the goal should be never to over-estimate your customers:
 
"Domino's announced the launch of its tattoo promotion—named 'Domino's Forever'—on its page on VKontakte, the Russian equivalent of Facebook , on Aug. 31. The conditions were minimal: Applicants should post a photo on social media of a real tattoo in a visible place with the hashtag #dominosforever. They would receive a certificate allowing them to receive 100 free pizzas a year of any size for 100 years, the company said. Russians hurried to tattoo parlors."
 
There are several examples of the tattoos in the online version of the article, with Domino's first placing narrower rules for those who qualify and then, after the number of postings piled up, cancelled the campaign altogether:
 
"Domino's later said 381 people qualified for free pizza in the four days or so that the promotion was running."
 
The logic driving those who wanted to get tattoos was far from failsafe:
 
"At his parlor in Moscow, Mr. Gonyshev, 29, said he tried to persuade the students not to add the tattoos, because it wasn't clear they would qualify for the free pizza. He said they replied that the logo was pretty cool and went ahead anyway."
 
Take care
David
 
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: https://study.sagepub.com/chandler4e
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Domino's Free Pizza Offer Backfires in Age of Ink
By James Marson and Thomas Grove
September 17, 2018
The Wall Street Journal
Late Edition – Final
A1
 

Wednesday, November 22, 2017

Strategic CSR - Coca-Cola (II)

Following on from Monday's Newsletter, the article in the url below quantifies one of the many social consequences for our obsession with soft-drinks (and plastic):
 
"Earlier this year Greenpeace revealed Coca-Cola is responsible for selling more than 100bn single-use plastic bottles across the globe every year – that's more than 3,000 every second."
 
The author (who is the executive director of Greenpeace UK) uses this statistic to criticize Coca-Cola's recent announcement (only in the UK) that it will increase the recycled content of its plastic bottles to 50%:
 
"[This] … shows a startling lack of ambition from the soft-drinks giant to tackle one of the greatest environmental challenges facing us: the plastic pollution choking our oceans. … This new plan is no game changer. Limited to operations in the UK, Coca-Cola's plans amount to increasing its existing target for recycled content by a mere 10%, launching yet another public awareness campaign to keep the focus on litterers, and trialing what appears will be little more than a promotional scheme for buying more Coca-Cola bottles."
 
Beyond criticizing this specific announcement, however, the author asks why the company is not being more ambitious in its targets:
 
"… is reaching 50% recycled content in three years' time significant? The truth is that 100% recycled bottles are feasible and have been rolled out for a number of soft drinks products over the past decade. In 2007, for example, Suntory's Ribena became the first major UK soft drink brand to use 100% recycled plastic. Coca-Cola, the world's biggest soft drinks company, is lagging far behind."
 
His skepticism seems warranted, based on prior performance targets that are announced with much fanfare, only to recede into the distance and get lost among the noise of day-to-day business:
 
"The company's plans, which it says it will reveal later this year, may feature a money-off voucher scheme to reward customers returning small Coca-Cola bottles to shops. … If the vouchers can be redeemed on yet more plastic Coca-Cola bottles, this will only boost the already staggering global plastic bottle sales of a million a minute. It's also worth pointing out that Coca-Cola's mildly higher goal to source 50% recycled content should be taken with a pinch of salt given the company's history of failing to keep its promises. Coca-Cola got less than half way to meeting its global 2015 target to source 25% of its plastic bottles from recycled or 'renewable' material, for example plant-based plastics. Globally the company reached a pitiful 7% recycled material."
 
The management of key resources (i.e., water and plastic) has to be a priority for Coca-Cola. The firm's social license is already threatened with the health consequences of the consumption of its products. It should be doing more to get out ahead of yet another threat to its business.
 
Happy Thanksgiving to those of you here in the U.S.
David
 
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: https://study.sagepub.com/chandler4e
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: https://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/
 
 
If you care so much, Coke, why aren't your bottles 100% recycled?
By John Sauven
July 13, 2017
The Guardian