The CSR Newsletters are a freely-available resource generated as a dynamic complement to the textbook, Strategic Corporate Social Responsibility: Sustainable Value Creation.

To sign-up to receive the CSR Newsletters regularly during the fall and spring academic semesters, e-mail author David Chandler at david.chandler@ucdenver.edu.

Friday, September 12, 2014

Strategic CSR - HFTs

The article in the url below from The Atlantic is a great riff on cheating that, in the process, puts high-frequency traders (HFTs) in their place (sorry, I meant in the correct context):
 
"It's Wall Street at its most socially useless. HFT funds aren't allocating capital to where they think it'll be most productive. HFT funds are allocating capital to where they think other people will put it 50 milliseconds from now. It's a tax on everybody else. And it's a tax that has basically no benefit. Sure, HFT funds defend themselves by saying they're increasing liquidity, but increasing liquidity is the last refuge of bullshitters. … Economist Paul Samuelson had it right all the way back in 1957: knowing (or trading) something one second before everyone else is personally profitable and socially pointless."

As everyone now knows, thanks to Michael Lewis' book, Flash Boys, the way HFTs make money is by front-running the market:
 
"The Wall Street Journal reports that HFT funds buy early access to data from third-party distributors—everything from corporate earnings to the Philadelphia Fed's manufacturing survey. They're getting the numbers just fractions of a second early, but that's more than enough in the world of high-frequency trading. … The private sector isn't paying for the creation of a public good when it buys a sneak peek at them. The private sector is just profiting off existing public goods. If a company sold hedge funds an early look at their earnings, it'd be insider trading. But when a third-party like Business Wire sells hedge funds an early, albeit split-second, look at corporate earnings, it's perfectly legal. It's nuts."
 
Of course, the important questions is: Who are the bigger idiots—the HFTs for doing what they are doing, or us for letting them get away with it?
 
Have a good weekend.
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


High-Speed Trading Isn't About Efficiency—It's About Cheating
By Matthew O'Brien
February 8, 2014
The Atlantic

Wednesday, September 10, 2014

Strategic CSR - Outsourcing

Outsourcing is an important issue in the CSR debate. While there are some industries that favor outsourcing more than others (and other industries that are starting to see some manufacturing and other operations returning onshore); in general, the debate over whether a company should or should not outsource is an economic one. As noted in the article in the url below, however, these same economic principles appear not to apply to the U.S. government—in particular, in relation to its military spending:
 
"As a case study, military footwear is pretty startling. Boot factories in rich countries are a rarity. Indeed Wolverine Worldwide—the Michigan-based company that owns Bates [a maker of military boots and shoes], along with such civilian brands as Merrell and Hush Puppies—makes almost all its other shoes [i.e., its nonmilitary boots] abroad, where labour costs are 30-40% lower."
 
In spite of the Bates factory in Michigan making most of its shoes overseas, the part of the company that makes military footwear is a 100% U.S. operation:
 
"… every component used there is American, from leather (a Minnesota tannery provides most hides) to shoelaces, eyelets and the yarn used for linings."
 
The push to manufacture using all-American raw materials, however, is driven neither by consumer-driven patriotism nor economic efficiency, but by political interference in an industry that manages to supply non-military shoes extremely efficiently:
 
"Military footwear is governed by the Berry amendment, passed by Congress on the eve of war in 1941 to ensure that troops would be given home-grown wool and food. Today the amendment applies to most uniforms, tents, flags and processed food bought with Pentagon funds. These must be entirely American-made or -grown, unless domestic firms simply do not make the product."
 
The U.S. defense budget is an important component of overall government spending because, in spite of recent announced cuts, it is still so large:
 
"America accounts for about four of every ten dollars spent on defence worldwide."
 
As such, finding easy ways to cut the total would be advantageous, although not, it seems, at the expense of making everything domestically, whatever the consequences in terms of costs. And, needless to say, military boots are not the only military need that must be supplied domestically:
 
"The rules are far stricter than those that apply to the federal government through the Buy American Act, which smiles on goods once they are more than half American. They are also amazingly complicated. One clause specifies that fish nuggets served to troops must contain only fish caught in American waters or by an American-flagged ship, but may use foreign breadcrumbs."
 
I am sure foreign breadcrumb makers are heaving a sigh of relief at that major concession!
 
Take care
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Boots on the ground
March 1, 2014
The Economist
Late Edition – Final
31
 

Monday, September 8, 2014

Strategic CSR - Natural Gas

As ever, unintended consequences serve to undermine even the best of intentions. The article in the url below indicates how efforts to reduce carbon emissions can actually end up increasing them (see: Strategic CSR – The Jevons Paradox). In particular, it focuses on efforts to convert various transportation vehicles (e.g., buses and trucks) from diesel to natural gas:
 
"Although burning natural gas as a transportation fuel produces 30 percent less planet-warming carbon dioxide emissions than burning diesel, the drilling and production of natural gas can lead to leaks of methane, a greenhouse gas 30 times more potent than carbon dioxide."
 
The research, which was conducted by researchers at Stanford, MIT, and the Department of Energy, concluded that the increase in methane emissions offset the savings that resulted from the fuel switch:
 
"Those methane leaks negate the climate change benefits of using natural gas as a transportation fuel. … The study concludes that there is already about 50 percent more methane in the atmosphere than previously estimated by the Environmental Protection Agency, a signal that more methane is leaking from the natural gas production chain than previously thought."
 
While switching from diesel to natural gas is a wash, however, the difference in emission levels is sufficiently large to make a switch from coal-fired power stations to natural gas-fired power stations worthwhile:
 
"Natural gas emits just half the carbon pollution of coal, and even factoring in the increased pollution from methane leaks, natural gas-fired plants lead to less emissions than coal over 100 years, the study found."
 
As usual, there is a solution that relies on an empowered stakeholder taking action. The methane, which leaks from "drilling wellheads, valves and pipelines," can be blocked if oil and gas companies are made to invest in existing technology that can prevent such leaks:
 
"The regulations would require that oil and gas companies install equipment at wellheads to capture the leaks, use valves in production facilities that do not allow methane to escape and have regular inspections."
 
Why energy companies are not being more progressive on this issue is puzzling, however, since they clearly have an economic incentive to minimize threats to the industry:
 
"The oil and gas industry has consistently resisted new regulations. Natural gas developers say that it is in their interest to capture methane since it is a component of natural gas and can be sold as such. Allowing it to escape causes them to lose money."
 
Take care
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/
 
 
Study Finds Methane Leaks Negate Benefits of Natural Gas as a Fuel for Vehicles
By Coral Davenport
February 14, 2014
The New York Times
Late Edition – Final
A12
 

Friday, September 5, 2014

Strategic CSR - Sustainability Reports

The article in the url below demonstrates one way that firms are responding to external pressures for CSR—sustainability reports:
 
"More companies in the S&P 500 index are touting their efforts to curtail greenhouse-gas emissions, reduce waste and improve their performance on other nonfinancial fronts. Last year, a record 72% of companies in the index filed sustainability reports, according to Governance & Accountability Institute Inc. That's up significantly from 53% in 2012 and 20% in 2011."
 
While, on the surface, this is encouraging; in reality, these documents reveal the limits of the ad hoc approach that has existed to date:
 
"The details disclosed by each company are selective, and often vary significantly among industry peers. Some companies use third-party benchmarks, while others only occasionally include hard numbers."
 
Until we are able to compare firms across industries, using common standards that measure what we think is important (rather than what firms are willing to tell us), these reports will remain selective and of limited value. While the title of the article heralds the fact that sustainability reports are gaining traction, the more important point is whether they are helping us understand which firms are meeting the needs and expectations of their broad range of stakeholders. In spite of the article's upbeat framing, that is much less clear.
 
Have a good weekend.
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Sustainability Reports Gain Traction
By Emily Chasan
June 10, 2014
The Wall Street Journal
Late Edition – Final
B8
 

Wednesday, September 3, 2014

Strategic CSR - Privacy

The debate around spying in the U.S. that has been generated by Edward Snowden has touched on many issues, such as the limits and oversight of government agencies. While important, the article in the url below argues that a more important debate about what this affair says about contemporary capitalism has been largely overlooked:

"… it is not just the NSA that is broken … too many governments, strapped for cash and low on infrastructural imagination, have surrendered their communications networks to technology companies a tad too soon."
 
In particular, while the abuses by the U.S. spy agencies are condemned, the author highlights what he terms:
 
"… the much more disturbing trend whereby our personal information – rather than money – becomes the chief way in which we pay for services – and soon, perhaps, everyday objects – that we use?"
 
In contrast to the general ignorance of the public about the listening and data gathering activities of the government, the author argues that we are willing accomplices when it comes to surrendering our private information (and, therefore, our privacy) to for-profit firms:
 
"No laws and tools will protect citizens who, inspired by the empowerment fairy tales of Silicon Valley, are rushing to become data entrepreneurs, always on the lookout for new, quicker, more profitable ways to monetise their own data – be it information about their shopping or copies of their genome. These citizens want tools for disclosing their data, not guarding it. Now that every piece of data, no matter how trivial, is also an asset in disguise, they just need to find the right buyer. Or the buyer might find them, offering to create a convenient service paid for by their data – which seems to be Google's model with Gmail, its email service."
 
In being willing to surrender our data, we are blind to the long-term consequences for capitalism and democracy of this new form of payment (substituting money for private data, which is then monetized by firms):
 
"The benefits to consumers are already obvious; the potential costs to citizens are not. As markets in personal information proliferate, so do the externalities – with democracy the main victim."
 
While new laws might quieten the debate in the short-term, the author presents a compelling case that we are missing the bigger picture that communication technologies are re-structuring our society:
 
"Unfortunately, these issues are not on today's agenda, in part because many of us have bought into the simplistic narrative – convenient to both Washington and Silicon Valley – that we just need more laws, more tools, more transparency. What Mr Snowden has revealed is the new tension at the very foundations of modern-day capitalism and democratic life. A bit more imagination is needed to resolve it."
 
Take care
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


The Snowden saga heralds a radical shift in capitalism
By Evgeny Morozov
December 27, 2013
Financial Times
Late Edition – Final
9
or
 

Monday, September 1, 2014

Strategic CSR - Climate change

The trouble with climate change is that we cannot agree what to do about it. One of the reasons for this is because there is a large chunk of the population that is apathetic about the approaching apocalypse. As the book review in the url below notes, a mixture of apathy and the scale of the problem leads to a lack of meaningful action:
 
"The changes occurring in Earth's climate appear to present an unfair fight, between the majestic forces of Nature and we minuscule humans, scurrying to protect ourselves. … Once you have contemplated the mind-boggling variety of bets that nations, businesses and politicians are placing based on predicted global temperatures, the choice of which gas-hybrid SUV to buy will seem trivial."
 
Worse than apathy, however, is that there are many people who stand to benefit from a deteriorating environment:
 
"Bad news for flood-stricken Bangladeshis, it turns out, is good news for Greenland's separatists, hoping to break free of Denmark and profit from an Arctic mineral boom. Russians are taking their lead from President Vladimir Putin, who has observed that the warming of his country means 'we shall save on fur coats.' Melting sea ice and permafrost would expand Russia's agricultural land, improve its fishing stocks and make it easier to extract minerals from Siberia. A Chinese company has signed a lease to farm 5% of Ukraine, some 7.5 million acres, to grow food for its home market."
 
The money-making schemes are varied, but all have a common theme—this is happening, so we might as well make money from it:
 
"Who knew that Israelis were the masters of artificial snow-making? It turns out to be a lucrative byproduct of their experience desalinating seawater to irrigate Israeli farms. Now their machines pump snow all over the Alps and will be in action at Sochi for the Winter Olympics. In Holland, engineers are rubbing their hands at the prospect of bringing a version of the dam system that protects Rotterdam to post-Sandy New York. And in Seattle, an ex-Microsoft scientist is scheming to pump sulfur into the stratosphere to shield polar ice from the sun."
 
And, of course, those best positioned to profit from climate change are the same actors who got us into this mess (i.e., us):
 
"It turns out that climate change is rather like the financial crisis. Those who may have caused it with their emissions are likely to profit most from it, and the gulf between the world's rich, who can protect themselves from its worst effects, and the poor, who cannot, will only widen. It is an ugly truth, but one well worth recognizing as we ponder what do if Maine turns into Tuscany and the Marshall Islands vanish beneath the sea."
 
Happy Labor Day!
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Of Seers and Profiteers
By Philip Delves Broughton
January 29, 2014
The Wall Street Journal
Late Edition – Final
A15
 

Friday, August 29, 2014

Strategic CSR - Carbon tax

Writing over the summer, Hank Paulson (yes, that Hank Paulson, George Bush's Treasury Secretary during the financial crisis) constructed one of the best arguments I have seen from the Republican Party in favor of action on climate change:
 
"The solution can be a fundamentally conservative one that will empower the marketplace to find the most efficient response. We can do this by putting a price on emissions of carbon dioxide — a carbon tax. Few in the United States now pay to emit this potent greenhouse gas into the atmosphere we all share. Putting a price on emissions will create incentives to develop new, cleaner energy technologies."
 
Of course, an intelligent argument on this issue from the right, does not mean many others on the right (or left, for that matter) will listen.
 
Have a good weekend.
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


The Coming Climate Crash
By Henry M. Paulson, Jr.
July 17, 2014
The New York Times
Late Edition – Final
SR1
 

Wednesday, August 27, 2014

Strategic CSR - Philanthropy

The article in the url below is a story about the level of charitable donations by FTSE 100 companies:
 
“The amount donated to charity by FTSE 100 companies – including cash, in-kind donations and the value of volunteered hours – has almost doubled, rising by £1.2bn since 2007, an average of 0.7% of pre-tax profits in 2012. It's a significant increase especially given the difficult economic factors in play during that time.”
 
The article appears in a newsletter published by The Guardian Sustainable Business Network (http://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business). In other words, The Guardian treats philanthropic donations as an important part of CSR/sustainability. It is unfortunate and counter-productive that this is the case—especially so since, essentially, the article also makes the case that such spending is not a very efficient investment for these firms. A big reason for this is that, apart from the nonprofit that received the gift, none of the firms’ other stakeholders are aware that these firms are spending their money in this way:
 
“When asked how many FTSE 100 companies make donations to charity every year, the average guess was just over a third. The reality is quite different – nearly all of the FTSE 100 companies (98%) – report giving every year. In 2012 all 100 reported making a donation.”
 
It is hard to understand why this situation persists. Why is philanthropy still considered a significant part of CSR? For some, no doubt, it is considered to be the primary component of CSR. But, this is ludicrous when you think through what it means. A common theme across definitions of CSR is the idea of “giving back.” In other words, how does the firm create value for society, broadly defined. It never ceases to amaze me that philanthropy should be considered by anyone to be the main vehicle in which a for-profit firm is supposed to “give back” to society. For-profit firms are efficient value-creating organizations. Now, to be sure, that value it not evenly distributed (and we can debate how effective they are at present and how effective they should be in an ideal world). But, nevertheless, for-profit firms create the most value for society as a whole when they focus on what they are good at, which is core operations.

The conclusion of the story below is that firms would benefit more from their donations if they just did a better job of communicating activity they are already doing (i.e., so that their donations become more widely known). What the article should have focused on is how much better off society would be if the firms just stopped giving charitable donations and, instead, invested that money in their core operations and product innovation.
 
Take care
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


New survey shows FTSE 100 companies have increased charitable giving
By Klara Kozlov
August 14, 2014
The Guardian
 

Monday, August 25, 2014

Strategic CSR - Starbucks

The article in the url below covers the summer announcement by Starbucks that it is willing to pay for the tuition of its employees to attend university—even part-time employees. The article offers a good summary of the agreement:
 
"On June 16th Howard Schultz, the boss of the coffee retailer, told a meeting in New York of hundreds of top-performing employees—and their families—that the firm will pay for their university education. From later this year, it will cover all the tuition fees in the final two years of college for staff who work at least 20 hours a week, and may also contribute to the cost of their first two years. The only conditions are that they must get their degree online from Arizona State University, and achieve a certain number of course credits."
 
I have seen some commentators complain that the employees have to pay a large amount out-of-pocket before Starbucks starts contributing (i.e., the first two years of tuition). Nevertheless, the benefit strikes me as exceedingly generous. The interesting question, therefore, is why would Starbucks do this? Beyond the "highly caffeinated PR" suggested in the article, one fact mentioned (almost as an afterthought) suggests one of the primary motivating factors:
 
"Although the attrition rate at Starbucks is well below the fast-food industry's average of around 110% a year, it is still said to turn over two-thirds of its workforce annually."
 
That is amazing. An average of 110% turnover means that most fast-food companies lose their entire workforce, on average, every year. While some people obviously stay on, which means that other positions are filled multiple times over, this is a huge cost of doing business in this industry. As such, if the "average fast-food company" has got any sense whatsoever, I would think it is something they are trying to fix. While high-school students working for extra pocket money are never going to stay around for long, it seems that offering fulfilling careers for the adult proportion of the workforce would be a good investment:
 
"[Howard Schultz, Starbucks CEO] thinks shareholders will benefit because employees will be more motivated and loyal. … Reducing [employee attrition], and thus the cost of recruiting, training and integrating new workers, could save a fortune. Mr Schultz says he hopes eventually to offer similar help with higher-education costs to employees outside America. … Starbucks is hardly the first firm to pay college fees for some staff, though other employers typically do so only to give them specific skills needed by the firm, and require them to remain on the payroll for some period after completing the course. Starbucks employees will have no such obligation, though Mr Schultz says he hopes they will see enough career potential with the company to want to do so."
 
Take care
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


From baristas to BA-ristas
June 21, 2014
The Economist
Late Edition – Final
63
 

Friday, August 22, 2014

Strategic CSR - Starbucks

The article in the url below, which reports on a series of events that occurred this week at a Starbucks in St. Petersburg, FL, is a good story to start the weekend:
 
"The acts of kindness began at 7 a.m. Wednesday with a woman, her iced coffee and a stranger's caramel macchiato. The woman paid for her own drink, then asked to pay for the drink of the person behind her in the drive-through. That person returned the favor and paid for the person behind, and so did that person, until the employees at the St. Petersburg Starbucks on Tyrone Boulevard began a tally on green laminated paper near the drive-through window. By 1:30 p.m., the chain had reached 260 customers."
 
How did the chain keep going?
 
"People ordered a drink at the speaker. When they pulled through to the next window, the barista, Vu Nguyen, 29, leaned through and said with a smile that their drinks had already been paid for by the person in front of them. Would they like to return the favor?"
 
Now, I recognize that a degree of peer group pressure was involved in extending the chain, with some customers saying "they didn't want to be the jerk to end it." But, still, there are not enough good stories to go around for me to pass this one up:
 
"The baristas inside began to think of what they might do if it lasted until 10 p.m., when the Starbucks closed. Perhaps they could put the final amount on a gift card and continue the next day? They tallied 378 people by early evening."
 
In the end, the chain lasted 11 hours. That is, an uninterrupted sequence of 378 customers who found out their drinks had been paid for by the customer in front and, in turn, agreed to pay for the customer behind them. There are stories of customers pulling up, hainvg only ordered a small coffee for themself, but being willing to pay for the order behind them of multiple drinks and sandwiches. There was also a report of one guy returning for another coffee later in the day to see if the chain was still going. Moreover, once news got out, it was reported that the line started up again the next day. The NPR story covering the event is here:
 
 
Now, if we could just get everyone to care about each other's planet to the same extent as they clearly care about each other's coffee!
 
Have a good weekend                                                  
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Nearly 400 people 'pay it forward' at St. Petersburg Starbucks 
By Weston Phippen
August 20, 2014
Tampa Bay Times
 

Wednesday, August 20, 2014

Strategic CSR - Welcome back!

 
 
Welcome back to the Strategic CSR Newsletter!
The first CSR Newsletter of the Fall semester is below.
As always, your comments and ideas are welcome.
 
 
I hope you all had a good summer.
 
As we dive into a new semester, the article in the url below offers a positive (??) thought to start us off on the right note—a lesson in how to convey power and authority:
 
"… a study called 'Using Abstract Language Signals Power,' published this month in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, shows that projecting power is incredibly simple. Just communicate in abstractions. Details convey weakness. In one of the seven experiments, participants read quotes from a politician who described an earthquake as killing 120 and injuring 400; later, when he simply said it was a national tragedy, subjects thought he was a better leader."
 
I find that as I go through life, navigating the complexities of trying to formulate the social responsibilities of the for-profit firm, what strikes me is the need for less complexity. Clearly, it is a little taxing for humanity to deal with the complexities of climate science, economic theory, and human psychology—much easier to stick our heads in the sand and hope it will all get better before we die. As the author of the study succinctly (but unhelpfully) put it:
 
"'Being completely vague will just make you sound stupid,' she explains. 'Bulls––– is best when it has a kernel of truth in it.'"
 
Just what we need in life—even less complex reality and even more duplicitous simplicity. I'll have to remember to pass that on to my students. After all, there's nothing much at stake, right?
 
Looking forward to a productive semester filled with complexity!
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


How to get ahead by Speaking Vaguely
By Joel Stein
July 21-27, 2014
Bloomberg Businessweek
63
 

Wednesday, May 14, 2014

Strategic CSR - See you in the Fall!

 
This will be the last CSR Newsletter of the Spring semester.
Have a great summer and I will see you in August!
 
 
I have been doing a lot of thinking recently about the core principles that underpin the concept of strategic CSR. As I mentioned in an earlier Newsletter this semester (Strategic CSR – The End of CSR), the main stimulus for this thinking is a new book I have been invited to write for the United Nations PRME collection (http://www.unprme.org/).
 
I will let you all know when this book is published (scheduled for early 2015). For now, however, I wanted to raise the principle that I have been getting the most pushback on – the idea that shareholders do not own the firm.
 
This position is something I have been researching for the past year-and-a-half and is based on an argument grounded in corporate law. Lynn Stout at Cornell Law School has done particularly good and important work on this issue. This debate has largely missed the management literature (and the rest of the business school, for that matter), but there is a very good 2010 paper in the Academy of Management Review that addresses the issue directly (Lan & Heracleous, ‘Rethinking Agency Theory: The View from Law,’ Vol. 35, Issue 2, pp. 294-314). Writing in Harvard Business Review (http://hbr.org/2010/04/the-myth-of-shareholder-capitalism/ar/1), these two authors conclude from their research that:
 
“Oddly, no previous management research has looked at what the legal literature says about the topic, so we conducted a systematic analysis of a century’s worth of legal theory and precedent. It turns out that the law provides a surprisingly clear answer: Shareholders do not own the corporation, which is an autonomous legal person. What’s more, when directors go against shareholder wishes—even when a loss in value is documented—courts side with directors the vast majority of the time. Shareholders seem to get this. They’ve tried to unseat directors through lawsuits just 24 times in large corporations over the past 20 years; they’ve succeeded only eight times. In short, directors are to a great extent autonomous.”
 
For those of you interested, I would point you towards this statement of corporate law by The Modern Corporation (http://themoderncorporation.wordpress.com/company-law-memo/) and, if you agree with what it says, to sign the online petition. As the statement concludes:
 
“Contrary to widespread belief, corporate directors generally are not under a legal obligation to maximise profits for their shareholders. … Where directors pursue [this] goal, it is usually a product not of legal obligation, but of the pressures imposed on them by financial markets, activist shareholders, the threat of a hostile takeover and/or stock-based compensation schemes.”
 
In terms of pushback when I raise this issue, most people respond by saying that ‘Of course shareholders are the “legally defined” owners of the firm.’ When pushed, however, no one can tell me what law or court decision it is that supposedly determines this fact. If it is so definitively stated in law, then I think it should be relatively easy for someone to be able to point to the relevant law or legal precedent. If that proves to be a challenge, then it seems to me that the issue most people think is decided is, in fact, debatable.
 
Watch this space for more information about the other nine principles that constitute strategic CSR (and the published book) later this year. And, any thoughts on this issue that you would care to pass on would be gratefully received. I am no corporate legal scholar, but I find the arguments of (a growing number of) legal scholars on this question to be compelling and persuasive.
 
Have a great summer.
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/
 

Monday, May 12, 2014

Strategic CSR - Markets vs. Governments

The article in the url below weighs the value of markets (and, in particular, for-profit firms) over government mandates in terms of being able to solve the largest problems we face as a society:
 
“… it's multinational corporations, and not governments or non-profits, that have the vast human and financial capital, advanced technology, international footprint, market power and financial motivation to solve the world's the world's most daunting problems.”
 
For example:
 
“… Johnson Controls joined real-estate firm Jones Lang LaSalle to retrofit the Empire State Building for energy efficiency in 2012. The Clinton Climate Initiative and Rocky Mountain Institute also collaborated on the project. The groups estimate the project will cut energy costs by 38%, saving $4.4m annually and reducing carbon emissions by 105,000 metric tons over 15 years. Given that the building sector consumes up to 40% of the world's energy, energy efficiency is key to reducing our energy use. Retrofitting for energy efficiency is good for the world, while also generating profit for Johnson Controls. The power of financial motivation, not just the desire to do good, solved this problem.”
 
The essence of the article, however, is not to demonstrate the isolated brilliance of for-profit firms, but to emphasize the instrumental nature of collaboration. Specifically, the article seeks to demonstrate the self-interest for firms of engaging with stakeholders to solve market-based problems:
 
“… many companies are starting to understand that energy efficiency, poverty reduction and access to healthcare, for example, are preconditions to their success and also offer rewarding business opportunities. Furthermore, customers, employees and investors are driving corporate accountability, transparency and adherence to labor and environmental norms. Reports indicate that businesses that ignore labor groups, grassroots organizations, consumers and civil society do so at their peril.”
 
Take care
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Business can do what governments can’t: Solve the world’s biggest problems
By Alice Korngold
January 7, 2014
The Guardian
 

Friday, May 9, 2014

Strategic CSR - CSR Reports

The article in the url below records baby steps towards the goal of more comprehensive CSR measuring and reporting:
 
“Major businesses in Europe will be required to produce social and environmental reports as part of their standard annual report following the passing of a law in the European Parliament.”
 
Unfortunately, of course, the legislative process is far from perfect and the best of intentions are subject to vested interests:
 
“The law was the subject of a lot of last-minute wrangling, with some countries expressing reservations that it would be an additional layer of bureaucracy for businesses. As a result, a considerable degree of flexibility was built into the final form of the legislation.”

In particular:
 
“Companies will be able to choose the relevant indicators against which they should report and a lot of large companies - particularly private companies - will be exempt from the law altogether. Reports will be audited, but don't have a requirement to be verified.”

On the plus side, however:
 
“… as a result of the law, some 6,000 companies will be required to report on areas such as human rights and the environment, diversity, corruption and social issues.”

Have a good weekend
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Mandatory reporting law passed by European Parliament
April 16, 2014
Business Respect
 

Wednesday, May 7, 2014

Strategic CSR - Taxes

I have long wondered why corporations avoiding state and federal taxes by incorporating overseas is not a bigger problem than it is. The recent decision by Starbucks to re-locate their European HQ to the UK (in order to pay a ‘fairer’ amount of tax) indicates stakeholders elsewhere are bringing pressure to bear on firms that seek to avoid contributing to the economies in which they operate. In the U.S., however, this issue has lagged. In the face of inaction by the federal government, individual states are gradually beginning to recoup their share of the lost revenue, which is significant:
 
“Offshore tax shelters cost the federal government $30 billion to $90 billion annually, according to a 2013 Congressional Research Service report. The U.S. Public Interest Research Group, which tracks corporate taxes, puts the amount that states lose at $20 billion a year.”
 
The states are doing so by passing legislation that counts revenues booked in overseas countries as taxable income that must be declared on the firms’ state income tax returns:
 
“Oregon enacted a bill last June for the 2014 tax year identifying 39 countries and territories—including Barbados, Liberia, and the U.S. Virgin Islands—as corporate shelters. The state counts profits that corporations and their subsidiaries stash in shelter countries as taxable income, and companies that do business in the state must report it on their state tax returns and pay up.”
 
Some firms will face significantly higher tax bills as a result:
 
“Microsoft, Apple, and IBM accounted for $37.5 billion, or 18.2 percent, of the total increase during the past year. Caterpillar avoided $2.4 billion in U.S. taxes over more than a decade by shifting profits from a parts business to a subsidiary in Switzerland, according to a report issued on March 31 by a Senate committee.”
 
There is scope for many other states to follow suit:
 
“Few of the states that have passed or are contemplating tax-haven legislation are home to a large multinational such as Microsoft, which is based in Washington, or Apple in California, IBM in New York, or Caterpillar in Illinois. Those states would stand to collect far more from such measures. California lost the most to offshore havens in 2011, an estimated $3.3 billion, the Public Interest Research Group reports.”
 
The graphic that accompanies the article provides additional detail:
 
 
Take care
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


U.S. States Target Corporate Cash Stashed Overseas
By Mark Niquette
April 17, 2014
Bloomberg Businessweek
 

Monday, May 5, 2014

Strategic CSR - IPCC

The article in the url below digs a little deeper into the recent IPCC climate change report and the details it uncovers are not encouraging:
 
“The [IPCC] describes itself as ‘policy-relevant and yet policy-neutral’. Its latest report, the third in six months, ignores that fine distinction. Pressure from governments forced it to strip out of its deliberations a table showing the link between greenhouse gases and national income, presumably because this made clear that middle-income countries such as China are the biggest contributors to new emissions. It also got rid of references to historical contributions, which show that rich countries bear a disproportionate responsibility.”
 
This is discouraging, not so much in terms of the overall findings in relation to climate change, but in terms of what it says about the governments that are supposed to negotiate a new climate change agreement (with associated commitments to lower emissions) next year in Paris:
 
“The new report is intended to measure how far governments have met their promises, formalised in 2010, to keep the global rise in mean surface temperatures compared with pre-industrial times to less than 2°C. It says they are miles from achieving that goal and are falling further behind.”
 
Why is this important? Primarily because the only way progress can be made in combatting the effects of climate change is with the coordinated cooperation of governments worldwide:
 
“The IPCC still thinks it might be possible to hit the emissions target by tripling, to 80%, the share of low-carbon energy sources, such as solar, wind and nuclear power, used in electricity generation. It reckons this would require investment in such energy to go up by $147 billion a year until 2030.”
 
In the same fashion that the IPCC gave-in to political pressure not to label those countries that have caused the most environmental damage, The Economist accuses the committee of holding back in terms of the financial consequences of addressing climate change seriously:
 
“These numbers look preposterous. Germany and Spain have gone further than most in using public subsidies to boost the share of renewable energy (though to nothing like 80%) and their bills have been enormous: 0.6% of GDP a year in Germany and 0.8% in Spain. The costs of emission-reduction measures have routinely proved much higher than expected.”
 
As a result:
 
“Of the IPCC’s three recent reports, the first two (on the natural science and on adapting to global warming) were valuable. This one isn’t.”
 
Take care
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/


Another week, another report
April 19, 2014
The Economist
Late Edition – Final
73
 

Friday, May 2, 2014

Strategic CSR - Subway

The video in the url below is revealing. It was produced by Consumer Reports following an investigation that compares photos of fast-food items taken from official company ads with photos of the actual food products as served to the reporters who compiled the report:
 
 
The “worst offender” identified in the video is Subway sandwich shop, which recently appeared in the CSR Newsletters for another, equally unflattering reason (Strategic CSR – Subway).
 
Eat fresh!
 
Have a good weekend
David
 
David Chandler & Bill Werther
 
Instructor Teaching and Student Study Site: http://www.sagepub.com/chandler3e/
Strategic CSR Simulation: http://www.strategiccsrsim.com/
The library of CSR Newsletters are archived at: http://strategiccsr-sage.blogspot.com/